If you are receiving payment in dollar stablecoins, holding a working balance, or paying suppliers across borders, you will have to decide which one you use. The honest short answer is that for most business purposes the difference matters less than people assume, and where it does matter it is about redemption and counterparty exposure rather than price.
Both trade at or very near a dollar. Neither is likely to fail tomorrow. The differences that should drive your decision are structural.
Who issues each, and what sits behind it
USDC is issued by Circle, a US company listed on the New York Stock Exchange since June 2025 under the ticker CRCL. That listing matters more than it might appear, because it means Circle files quarterly and annual reports with the SEC containing audited financial statements, in addition to its stablecoin reserve reporting.
Circle discloses reserve holdings weekly, alongside mint and redemption flows, and publishes monthly attestations by a Big Four accounting firm prepared under AICPA attestation standards. As at 24 September 2026, USDC in circulation stood at approximately $75.2 billion.
The majority of reserves sit in the Circle Reserve Fund, a government money market fund registered under Rule 2a-7 of the Investment Company Act, managed by BlackRock and custodied at BNY Mellon. The fund holds short-dated US Treasury securities and overnight Treasury repurchase agreements, overcollateralised by Treasuries. The remainder is cash held at regulated financial institutions for daily mint and redemption flow.
Circle lists the Treasury holdings at individual security level, with each CUSIP and maturity date. In recent reports every Treasury position matured within roughly three months. That is an unusual degree of visibility: you can verify the maturity profile yourself rather than taking a stated average on trust.
USDT is issued by Tether, a private company, and is the larger of the two by a wide margin, with roughly $185 billion in circulation as of early 2026 against approximately $77 billion of USDC.
Tether publishes quarterly attestations performed by BDO Italia. Its reserves are majority US Treasury exposure, held directly and through money market funds and repo, but unlike USDC they also include other assets: gold, bitcoin, secured loans and corporate bonds. Its Q1 2026 attestation reported around $141 billion in Treasury and short-term exposure alongside roughly $50 billion in non-Treasury assets. Because the cadence is quarterly rather than weekly, the most recent published position is by definition older than Circle's.

Figures from each issuer's published reserve reporting. Attestations are point-in-time confirmations rather than audits, and neither issuer had published a completed full audit of reserves as of mid-2026.
One distinction worth understanding properly: an attestation is not an audit. It confirms that reserves matched tokens in circulation on a specific date. It does not examine internal controls or custody arrangements across a period. As of mid-2026, no major stablecoin issuer had published a completed full audit of its reserves, though Tether announced a Big Four engagement in March 2026.
Redemption is the real difference
For a business, the practical difference is less about what backs the token and more about how you get out of it.
Direct redemption with either issuer is available to account holders meeting their requirements, at size, through a process that takes time and paperwork. Most businesses will never do this. They will sell into a market or convert through a provider, which means the relevant question is not the issuer's redemption policy but the depth of the market you are actually selling into.
That reframing matters, because it moves the decision from a question about Circle and Tether to a question about your own corridor.
Liquidity in African markets
Here the answer diverges sharply from what a US or European guide would tell you.
In South Africa, Nigeria and Kenya, USDT is the dominant dollar stablecoin by a wide margin in local trading pairs. Search behaviour alone tells the story: local currency pairs against USDT attract many multiples of the volume that USDC pairs do.
The practical consequence is that if you need to convert a dollar stablecoin into rand, naira or shillings, USDT will usually give you better depth and a tighter achieved rate simply because more of the local market is quoting it. A theoretically superior reserve structure is worth very little if converting it costs you more in spread.
Which to hold, for what
• Receiving from international counterparties: Whichever they send. Most large US and European counterparties default to USDC; most emerging market counterparties default to USDT.
• Holding as working capital: Consider reserve structure and disclosure here, because this is where you carry exposure over time rather than momentarily.
• Converting to local currency: Follow the liquidity, which in African corridors generally means USDT.
• Larger balances: Holding both spreads issuer exposure and gives you the better side of whichever conversion you need.
The most common sensible answer for a business operating across several markets is both, in different proportions for different purposes. That is not a fudge. Issuer concentration is a genuine risk, and the two tokens are not equally liquid in every market you might need to exit through.
The US framework now distinguishes between them
The GENIUS Act, signed into US law in July 2025, defines what a payment stablecoin is and sets requirements for issuers, including one-to-one reserves held in cash or short-dated Treasuries and mandatory monthly attestations.
That matters for this comparison because the two tokens sit differently in relation to it. Circle's structure, reserve composition and reporting cadence were already built around that kind of requirement. Tether's reserve mix includes asset classes the framework does not contemplate for a payment stablecoin, and its attestation cadence is quarterly rather than monthly.
For a business, the practical question is not which token is more virtuous. It is whether your own regulatory obligations, or those of your counterparties and banking partners, are likely to push you toward a stablecoin issued under a recognised framework. For some businesses that will matter a great deal and for others not at all, but it is worth establishing before you build a treasury process around one token.
The regulatory position in our markets
In South Africa, the FSCA declared crypto assets a financial product under the FAIS Act in October 2022, and crypto asset service providers have required licensing since June 2023. By the end of 2025 the FSCA had received 512 licence applications and approved around 300, the largest licensed population on the continent. The South African Reserve Bank does not recognise crypto assets as currency, and the FSCA's remit covers the conduct of service providers rather than the assets themselves.
In Kenya, the Virtual Asset Service Providers Act 2025 commenced on 4 November 2025, with implementing regulations gazetted in July 2026. Licensing is split between the Central Bank of Kenya and the Capital Markets Authority, and it covers offshore platforms serving Kenyan customers as well as local ones.
Neither framework distinguishes between USDC and USDT. Both treat the activity rather than the token, which means your choice between them is a commercial and treasury decision rather than a compliance one.




